Food blog

The Ultimate Guide to Fixing Runny Custard: This Trick Will Save Your Desserts!

Fixing Runny Custard: The Ultimate Guide

Homemade custard is a delightful ingredient that forms the basis of many delicious desserts. Its creamy, smooth texture adds richness and flavor to dishes like creme brulee, custard pudding, flan, custard cake, and even comforting treats like banana pudding or custard ice cream. But despite its culinary appeal, custard can sometimes be a challenge to perfect, resulting in a runny consistency that leaves us disappointed.

The challenge of making custard

Custard presents a unique set of difficulties due to its egg-based composition. Achieving the ideal texture requires careful cooking, as undercooked custard can fail to set, while adding eggs to a mixture that is too hot can result in unwanted scrambled eggs.
If you are faced with a runny custard, fear not, there are effective solutions. Whether you’ve already refrigerated a custard that hasn’t thickened or it hasn’t set enough to even go in the fridge, there are remedies that can help you salvage your dessert.

Reheating the custard

One way to deal with a pudding that refuses to set is to reboil it. If you find that your custard is thickening, but then becomes thin after refrigeration, you can simply return the custard base to a saucepan and continue cooking. By reheating the custard, you give it a chance to thicken again.

Introducing Thickeners

If reboiling does not produce the desired consistency, you can turn to the use of thickeners to save your runny custard. There are three commonly used ingredients that can help thicken custard, each offering a reliable solution for the contents of your pantry.

1. Baking flour

Flour is a versatile thickening agent that is easily found in most kitchens. To use flour as a thickening agent, mix two tablespoons of flour with four tablespoons of cold water for each cup of custard. Make sure the flour is thoroughly incorporated into the water, then whisk it into the custard mixture as it cooks on the stove. The flour will gradually thicken the custard to the desired consistency.

2. Cornstarch

If you prefer an alternative to flour, cornstarch is an excellent option. To use cornstarch as a thickening agent, combine one tablespoon of cornstarch with one tablespoon of water for each cup of custard. Mix the cornstarch and water thoroughly, then whisk it into the pudding mixture as it cooks. The cornstarch will work its magic, transforming the runny pudding into a rich, thickened delight.

3. Tapioca

For those looking for a unique twist in their thickening journey, tapioca can come to the rescue. Use one teaspoon of tapioca with one tablespoon of water per cup of pudding. Whisk the tapioca and water together until well combined, then stir into the custard mixture during the cooking process. The tapioca will contribute its thickening properties to help you achieve the perfect consistency for your pudding.

Adjusting the cooking temperature

If your pudding remains runny after using thickening agents, you may need to adjust the cooking temperature. However, be careful when doing so. Increasing the heat abruptly can result in scrambled eggs in the custard mixture. Gradually increase the cooking temperature while closely monitoring the consistency of the custard to prevent overcooking.
With these valuable tips and techniques at your disposal, you can confidently tackle the challenge of fixing runny custard. Seize the opportunity to save your dessert and transform it into a velvety, indulgent treat that will be the highlight of any meal. Don’t let a little setback keep you from achieving custard perfection. Happy cooking!


Why did my pudding come out runny?

Custard can be runny for a number of reasons, including undercooking or improper egg tempering. It’s important to follow the recipe instructions and cook the custard until it thickens to the desired consistency.

Can I fix a custard that has been refrigerated and has become runny?

Yes, you can fix a runny custard that has been refrigerated. Simply reboil the custard by returning it to a saucepan and continuing to cook. This will allow for additional thickening and help restore the consistency of the custard.

What do I do if my pudding hasn’t set enough to go into the refrigerator?

If your pudding hasn’t set enough to be refrigerated, you can add thickeners such as flour, cornstarch, or tapioca. These ingredients help thicken the pudding during the cooking process and bring it to the desired consistency.

How much flour or cornstarch should I use to thicken my pudding?

For each cup of custard, you can use two tablespoons of flour mixed with four tablespoons of cold water. Alternatively, you can use one tablespoon cornstarch mixed with one tablespoon water. Adjust the amounts based on the amount of custard you’re working with.

Can I use tapioca to thicken my pudding?

Yes, tapioca can be used to thicken pudding. For each cup of pudding, mix one teaspoon of tapioca with one tablespoon of water. Incorporate this mixture into the pudding as it cooks, and the tapioca will help thicken the pudding.

Should I adjust the cooking temperature if my pudding remains runny?

If your custard remains runny after adding thickening agents, you may consider adjusting the cooking temperature. However, be careful not to scramble the eggs. Gradually increase the heat while monitoring the consistency of the custard to avoid overcooking.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *