Food blog

The Sweet Truth Unveiled: Everything You Need to Know About Costco Sheet Cakes

The Truth About Costco Sheet Cakes

When it comes to satisfying a sweet tooth and feeding a crowd, Costco sheet cakes have become a go-to choice for many. Known for their generous size and affordability, these massive confections have garnered a loyal following among Costco members. But what exactly is the truth about Costco pancakes? Let’s dive in and uncover the facts.

The Costco Sheet Cake Phenomenon

People flock to Costco for a variety of reasons, whether it’s for their bulk household items or their famous rotisserie chicken. However, one of the most compelling reasons to become a Costco member is their sheet cake. Year after year, Costco’s sheet cakes have been a popular choice for those planning multiple birthday parties or other special occasions.
Despite rumors of the sheet cake’s demise, it turns out that these sweet treats are still available to Costco members. Costco sheet cakes are a great value and consist of two 12″ x 16″ layers of cake separated by a fluffy, creamy mousse and covered in real buttercream frosting. They are technically half-sheet cakes and offer a generous portion size that can feed a small army or a classroom full of hungry middle schoolers.

A design for every occasion

Costco’s bakery team goes above and beyond when it comes to cake designs. They offer a wide variety of frosting illustrations to decorate your sheet cake, with options ranging from birthday themes like rainbows and princess crowns to designs for religious celebrations and graduations. If none of the pre-designed options appeal to you, Costco also takes custom orders a few days in advance, allowing their talented cake artists to create a special design or personal message just for you.

Flavorful options

While Costco’s sheet cakes offer an impressive variety of designs, they are only available in two flavors in the United States. The first option is a white cake layered with vanilla cheesecake mousse and topped with decadent vanilla buttercream frosting. The second option is a chocolate cake filled with chocolate mousse and topped with chocolate buttercream frosting. Although the flavor options are limited, these classic combinations have proven to be crowd favorites.
It’s worth noting that Costco’s Australian stores offer additional flavor options, including the option to add raspberry or chocolate filling to either the chocolate or vanilla sponge cake. Despite the limited flavor options, Costco’s sheet cakes continue to be appreciated by customers for their quality and freshness.

Caloric indulgence

If you’re watching your calories, Costco’s sheet cakes may not be the ideal choice. A single three-ounce serving of either the chocolate or vanilla flavors of Costco’s frosted/filled sheet cake is estimated to provide about 400 calories. These cakes are also high in sugar, with a single serving of chocolate frosting containing about 44 grams of sugar and the vanilla frosting version containing about 49 grams. It’s important to keep these numbers in mind and enjoy these indulgent treats in moderation.

Wallet-friendly indulgence

One of the most appealing aspects of Costco’s sheet cakes is their affordability. At $24.99, these cakes offer great value for their size and quality. Compared to the high prices of high-end independent patisseries or even regular local bakeries, Costco’s sheet cakes are a steal. Many customers have even praised the taste of these cakes, claiming they rival those from fancy bakeries.

Feeding a crowd

Costco’s half-sheet cakes are designed to satisfy a large group of dessert lovers. Weighing in at nine and a half pounds, these cakes can serve up to 48 people. At just over 50 cents per person, Costco’s sheet cakes are a cost-effective option for parties, events, or even as a special treat for key employees.

Shelf life and storage

When it comes to keeping your Costco sheet cake fresh, proper storage is key. It is recommended to refrigerate the cake, as leaving it at room temperature can cause it to spoil more quickly and lose moisture. A refrigerated cake with buttercream frosting can last anywhere from three to four days, although this may be slightly shorter for cakes filled with creamy mousse.
Some Costco customers have reported that their cakes stay fresh in the refrigerator for up to a week or slightly longer. Freezing individual slices is also an option, allowing you to enjoy the cake for up to three months or even longer if properly wrapped. However, if you’re buying a Costco sheet cake for a specific event, it’s best to do so as close to the occasion as possible and store it unopened in the refrigerator until serving time.

Bottom line

Costco sheet cakes have earned their reputation as crowd pleasers and great value. With their generous size, customizable designs and classic flavors, these cakes have become a staple for birthdays, celebrations and get-togethers. While they may not be the healthiest option when it comes to calories and sugar, they offer a delicious indulgence for those special occasions when you want to treat yourself and your loved ones.
So the next time you are in need of a delicious and affordable dessert that can feed a crowd, consider heading to Costco and picking up one of their legendary sheet cakes. You’ll be joining the ranks of satisfied customers who have discovered the truth about Costco sheet cakes and are eager to enjoy their sweet and satisfying goodness.


Are Costco sheet cakes still available?

Yes, despite rumors to the contrary, Costco sheet cakes are still available to Costco members.

What size are the Costco sheet cakes?

Costco Sheet Cakes are half sheet cakes that measure approximately 12″ x 16″.

Can I customize the design of a Costco cake?

Absolutely! Costco offers a wide variety of pre-designed cake options for different occasions, and they also take custom orders for personalized designs or messages.

What flavors are available for Costco cakes?

In the United States, Costco sheet cakes come in two flavors: white cake with vanilla cheesecake mousse and vanilla buttercream frosting or chocolate cake with chocolate mousse and chocolate buttercream frosting.

How many people can you serve with a Costco sheet cake?

A Costco sheet cake can serve up to 48 people, making it perfect for large gatherings or events.

How should I store a Costco sheet cake?

It is recommended to refrigerate the cake to keep it fresh. A refrigerated cake with buttercream frosting will keep for about 3-4 days, while cakes with creamy mousse fillings may have a slightly shorter shelf life. Freezing individual slices is also an option for longer storage.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *