Food blog

Crunchy Pickles 101: Why Using Large Cucumbers is a Big Mistake

Why using large cucumbers is a mistake when making pickles

If you’re a pickle fan, you know that the perfect pickle has a signature crunch that adds a delicious texture to any dish. But achieving that ideal crunch can be a challenge, especially if you’re using the wrong pickles. In fact, one of the most common mistakes people make when making pickles is choosing large cucumbers instead of smaller ones. In this article, we’ll explore why using large cucumbers is a mistake when making pickles and provide you with valuable tips to ensure that your pickling efforts are a success.

The Importance of Size in Pickling

When it comes to pickling cucumbers, size really does matter. While it may seem logical to use larger cucumbers to make larger pickles, this is not the case. Large cucumbers have a higher water content than smaller ones, which can result in soft and limp pickles. In addition, larger cucumbers tend to have more seeds, which can be unpleasant in a pickle. For the perfect pickle texture, it’s best to choose smaller cucumbers.

Choosing the Right Pickling Cucumbers

To make sure your pickles are crunchy and delicious, it’s important to choose the right pickling cucumbers. During the summer months (between June and August), you’ll find a wide variety of pickling cucumbers at farm stands. These cucumbers, such as gherkin, cornichon, Kirby, and bush cucumbers, are small, about the size of a thumb. They are specially bred to make tasty pickles and have the perfect crunch. However, if you’re making pickles in other months, mini English cucumbers are a great alternative. They have a thin skin that allows the brine to penetrate effectively, and they retain a firm texture.

The Science of Pickling

Pickling is not just a random process; there is a science behind it. To get the best results, it’s important to understand the key factors involved. In addition to choosing the right pickles, you’ll need a few other ingredients. Pickling salt is recommended because it contains no additives and dissolves quickly in your brine solution. Look for vinegar with an acidity of 5%, and if you’re unsure, white distilled vinegar is a reliable choice. While vinegar is the primary flavoring agent in pickles, you can also enhance the flavor by adding fresh spices. Be careful with powdered spices, however, as they can cloud the brine.

Tips for successful pickling

Now that you understand the importance of using small cucumbers and the science behind pickling, let’s explore some additional tips for successful pickling:

  1. Select cucumbers that are fresh and firm: Choose cucumbers that are firm to the touch and free of any soft spots or blemishes. Freshness is key to achieving the desired crunch in your pickles.
  2. Prepare cucumbers properly: Wash cucumbers thoroughly and trim both ends. If you’re using larger cucumbers, scoop out the seeds and dice them to make cucumber relish instead.
  3. Use the correct brine solution: Dissolve pickling salt in water to make a brine solution. The ratio of salt to water depends on the recipe you’re using, so follow the directions carefully.
  4. Allow the cucumbers to soak in the brine: Place the cucumbers in the brine and make sure they are completely submerged. Leave to soak for the recommended time to allow the flavors to develop.
  5. Store pickles properly: When your pickles are ready, store them in clean, airtight containers in the refrigerator. This will help keep them fresh and crisp.

By following these tips and avoiding the mistake of using large cucumbers, you’ll be well on your way to creating delicious, crunchy pickles that will enhance your meals and snacks.
Remember, pickling is a fun and rewarding culinary endeavor, so don’t be afraid to experiment with different flavors and spices to create unique pickling recipes. Enjoy the process and the tangy goodness of homemade pickles!


Can I use large cucumbers to make pickles?

It is not recommended to use large cucumbers for pickling. They have a higher water content and more seeds, resulting in soft and less desirable pickles.

Why are smaller cucumbers better for pickling?

Smaller cucumbers have a lower water content and fewer seeds, which contribute to a crunchy and crisp texture in pickles.

Can I replace large cucumbers with other varieties?

Yes, you can replace large cucumbers with pickling cucumbers such as gherkin, cornichon, Kirby or bush cucumbers. Alternatively, mini English cucumbers are a good choice in months when pickling cucumbers are not readily available.

What is the role of pickling salt in the pickling process?

Pickling salt is recommended because it contains no additives and dissolves quickly in the brine solution, providing a clear and flavorful pickling liquid.

Can I use powdered spices in the pickling process?

It’s best to use fresh spices when pickling, as powdered spices can cloud the brine. Fresh spices will enhance the flavor of your pickles without affecting their clarity.

How do I store homemade pickles?

Store your homemade pickles in clean, airtight containers in the refrigerator. This will help keep them fresh and crisp for longer.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *