Reynolds Kitchens Slow Cooker Liners: Are They Worth the Hype?
Okay, fellow slow cooker fanatics, let’s get real about something that’s been tempting us all: Reynolds Kitchens Slow Cooker Liners. As someone who leans on her slow cooker like a trusty sidekick at least twice a week – because who has time for complicated dinners, am I right? – the promise of ditching that awful scrubbing part? Seriously tempting.
The Big Sell:

These liners boast that they’ll slash your slow cooker cleanup to practically nothing. We’re talking eight seconds flat! Designed to cozy up inside 3- to 8-quart slow cookers, they’re made with a BPA-free material that can handle the heat (up to 400 degrees, no less). But the real kicker? Saying goodbye to that baked-on food nightmare.
My Two Cents:
I’ve put these liners through their paces with a few different meals now. First up: a super simple chicken chili. And you know what? It was magic! Cleanup was, honestly, a breeze. Lifted the liner, gave the slow cooker a quick once-over, and boom – done. I almost felt smug, like I’d unlocked some secret level of adulting.
Then came the pulled pork. Ah, yes…pulled pork. This is where the fairy tale hit a snag. Even after giving the liner a good spritz with cooking spray, bits of that delicious pork decided to cling on for dear life. It wasn’t a total disaster, mind you, but it definitely wasn’t that effortless, lift-and-toss experience I was dreaming of.
The Good Stuff:
- Cleanup Can Be a Breeze (Sometimes): When these liners work, they really work. Think soups, stews, anything that’s not super sticky.
- BPA-Free Peace of Mind: Always a win when you’re cooking for your crew.
- Fits Like a Glove (Mostly): The 13 x 21 inch size plays nice with most standard slow cookers.
The Not-So-Good Stuff:
- Not a Guaranteed Get-Out-of-Scrubbing-Free Card: As my pulled pork saga proves, these aren’t foolproof. Sticky situations can still happen.
- One-and-Done Deal: Yep, you gotta use a fresh liner every time, which can feel a little wasteful, let’s be honest.
- Meltdown Alert? Okay, I haven’t seen it myself, but I’ve heard whispers about these liners melting at higher temps. So, keep an eye on things, just in case.
The Bottom Line:
Reynolds Kitchens Slow Cooker Liners? They’re a handy shortcut, no doubt, but don’t expect a miracle. For some meals, they’re a total game-changer. For others, you might still need to roll up your sleeves a bit. My advice? Stick to using them for less-sticky recipes, and maybe give them a little extra love with some cooking spray for good measure.
My Rating: I’m giving them a solid 3.5 out of 5 stars. They definitely save time and hassle, but they don’t completely eliminate the cleanup struggle.
